What island for the Pirate Hall?

I'm pretty determined in buying Pirate Halls for crew and flag.
What archipelago and island should they be on? I kind of not like Admiral and the Gull.

What the hell is a Pirate hall?

Oremus wrote:What the hell is a Pirate hall?

This.

Nice. So, it's basically like a house...but for flag/crew.

I really like the idea of having a meeting place for flag members. I particularly like the idea of having rooms for official functions and then places where people just hang out. That would bring some real "geography" to the community by having the idea of a crew centered around a "physical" spot.

On the subject of islands, I don't know. If you're really interested in official functions then I'd suggest somewhere out of the way to make it fairly exotic. But then if you want to be the second idea of the home of crew, then I'd go for somewhere very easy to get to.

Oremus wrote:But then if you want to be the second idea of the home of crew, then I'd go for somewhere very easy to get to.

Well, if people set the island where the PH is built as their home, this issue should be solved.

Certainly, the issue would be solved but it would create a whole other issue of you'd have to use a whisk/alt to go the island where you have your vessels/shops/homes etc. To be fair, I don't mind too much.

What size were you thinking of?

i want the bigger pirate hall!!! xD

what about scrim or bowditch then? this 2 or in the gull arch would be the best place for the pirate hall

Choosing where to have a pirate hall, even as a personal house is difficult.

I do not think there is any problem anyone getting to the hall. My main has access to its flag hall from the home/houses button on the main news page. So currently I get the option of original shack, estate, and flag hall to wizz to directly.

if anything to me the question is more about is there an advantage in having a hall in an archipelago far off that is not easily available by any other free means.